Local Elections Fallout: Plus ça Change…


Heads are rolling in Hollande’s government, but the story has many echoes of the past

A veritable blue wave has swept across the country that was so hopeful that their future was going to be a red one just a few short years ago as the right won through in overwhelming fashion, taking 155 towns. Paris stood alone amongst the survivors of the routing, with Anne Hidalgo holding onto the capital, taking over from the highly popular Bertrand Delanoë.

The extreme right-wing Front National is now the third party of the republic and the results see it with 11 mayors, including significant towns such as Béziers and Fréjus.

The performance of Hollande as president is something that French voters are not hopeful of any more and there seems to be something in the results that is longing for a return to the days of a smart-alec go-getter president who knew how to pull the rabbit out of the hat when required (i.e. such as Nicolas Sarkozy).

Instead, Hollande has reacted by stamping his authority on the situation. Jean-Marc Ayrault – the man who came to the post of Prime Minister as the ultimate organiser and achiever from his reign as mayor of Nantes – was the one who had to take the hit for the dreadful results in the local elections. In his place, is the most popular politician in the Hollande administration – Manuel Valls (main picture).

The national press in France has focused on this choice of Hollande, with many seeing it as a last-ditch play of a desperate man eager to win back the popularity of the masses after a disastrous year of unimpressive economic performance and dithering and public humiliation over his private life.

A number of newspaper headlines have played on the surname of the new Barcelona-born Prime Minister and the word “valse“, meaning “waltz” to talk about the change of dancing partner of the President and wonder where this merry dance will lead the country over the next three years.

There are many comparisons too between the situation that Hollande finds himself in now and that of a Socialist president from another era François Mitterand. He was elected as head of state on a huge red tide in 1981 only to see a large blue tide wipe away much of his power in the 1983 local elections. In his case, Mitterand altered his policy rather than his cabinet and held out until 1988 before giving in to the temptation to reshuffle and to dump his popular Prime Minister Michel Rocard.

"Is Valls right-wing?" asks this headline in Le Figaro Magazine

“Is Valls right-wing?” asks this headline in Le Figaro Magazine

One local paper (Le Journal de Haute-Marne) notes that the major cabinet reshuffle and the ousting of such a star as Ayrault was “the price that had to be paid so as not to expect failure in the 2022 presidential elections”. “François Hollande has killed his best friend,” says Midi Libre, “and gives us a re-run of ‘Mitterand’ who forced the popular Rocard to leave in 1988”.

There’s also talk of the risk of bringing in 51-year-old Manuel Valls. In Les Echos, they believe that “Manuel Valls is a risk because it’s not certain that he’ll succeed in turning the country around… The worst part of it is that he’s also a risk if he succeeds.”

In the left-leaning L’Humanité, Patrick Apel-Muller is doubtful of the arrival of Valls which, he says, “confirms that François Hollande has turned a deaf ear to the country” and warns that “the choice of Mauel Valls reassures the right, worries the left and causes a bristling amongst the greens, who will have seen this final play coming and who will be keeping their distance from now on.”

This theme of Valls threatening to overshadow the president is a recurring one and many see parallels between the rise of the energetic Valls and that of his right-wing counterpart Nicolas Sarkozy. Like Valls, he came through as a highly popular Interior Minister to become Prime Minister only to overshadow the (then) president Jacques Chirac, even becoming party leader while the president was still in office.

scroll to top

We use cookies on this website primarily to improve its functionality. Along with typical standard cookies, we also use cookies and content from Google (maps, YouTube, FaceBook, Twitter) to improve the performance of this site. In order to ensure compliance with the General Data Protection Requirements, all cookies and content from Google, Twitter, Facebook and co. are deactivated by default. They will only be activated once you click "Accept" to allow the use of cookies and third-party content. If you initially choose not to accept cookies, you will not be able to watch videos or access other media content on this site. However, you can change this setting on any page containing third-party media by selecting the option to allow content. On the Privacy Policy page under “Cookies” you have the option to give or revoke your consent to the use of cookies. For more information please click the link below to read our: Privacy Policy

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.